Before obtaining best-in-slot gear, pick gear and meld according to stat priority on each piece of gear. A detailed breakdown of Paladin's stat priority is included at the bottom of this page.
Because of stat tiering, the Tank Gear Calculator gets the last word on any specific gearing questions.
Highest priority
-------------------------
Weapon Damage (main-hand weapon only)
Strength
Critical Hit
Skill Speed
Direct Hit
Determination
Tenacity
-------------------------
Lowest priority